Chick....just now looking at the filler tube seal on the cap, is that a rubber gasket with a thin metal support underneath? My original does not have any rubber on the seal area....it is all metal with a raised ring that seats on the filler tube.
OK guys...here's the facts. Old age is creeping up on (more likely has caught up with) me.
When I made this post I was going by memory, I was at my sons house and far away from the cap. Now that I am home again, I thought I had better take another look at my cap.... well guess what...my memory failed me big time.
There is a raised ring on the metal area but it is topped by a rubber washer seal. I had taken the rubber washer off to look at the metal underneath and forgot to put it back. So, If you do run across one without the rubber washer seal, I would say that it probably fell off or was removed and was never replaced.
Sorry for the false alarm...but at least now, I know for sure not to depend solely on my memory...