I assume the number on the belt matches the cover assy it arrived in, and yes, that 1/2" does matter. A local NAPA will have a belt gauge to verify the length. Give Janis a call if they shipped the wrong belt or if it's short. I see the revised chart you showed is from June 67. When was your car built? Let us know what happens. Also, I would have the old belt measured as well. Interestingly the 68 part numbers are different than 67 don't know the length.