Kurt is right (as usual) - pretty darn close. The OE is on the left, NOS on the right. Details right down to the "staple" marks are exactly the same in my view. Looking at the part numbers, you can tell they were made by the same suppier, if not the exact same mold. I may have labeled the part number pics wrong - the one listed as OE is probably the NOS - I think that's a '95 date stamping you can see below the part number.
Same weights, same materials. They are both heavy ABS, or whatever combination of plastic. The only thing I can't guarantee is if they made any vendor changes in the last year or two -
Regards,
Steve