Mine a 68 so it's got the satin finish.
I'm not too worried about the finish right now because if I buy these, they will have to be redone anyway.
It's more the fitting of the molding.
I saw the other post already.
When you look at the 67 aftermarket where the end piece is welded on, it's not a nice fit. And the first picture i posted has the same crappy look to it. . But is doesn't have the messy spot weld marks. That's why I'm not sure.
Do factory ones look like that, or are boths end nice clean looking with no gaps where the ends are welded on?