Bryon, are you saying you'd accept that stamp pad as 'original'??
Nope. I defer to others for their opinions in this one. I can’t tell based on the extremely poor pics. I like good clear pics. But if William says it is not good, I accept that.
Just saying that I have seen a lot of variation in original broach marks.
Here is an example of fairly deep broach marks. But I have seen some deeper.