My original goal was just to have them re-vinyl over the original vinyl. They tried this, but he said it looked awful because it showed all the misshaped issues of the original pad. I was going to ask him to just return it, I'll keep the original as-is, when he told me they already removed the original vinyl. Then I knew I was already past a point of any return, so I asked my wife to drop off my other old 8track player for them to use as a form and take a picture.
The "funny" part of the story is this picture where the upholstery man is holding it, asking my wife if he could make the sides longer so he could cover the holes. I screamed no no no, exactly as is! She put me on speaker then...